Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Chapter 12 (The Water is Wide)


“I don’t think I changed the quality of their lives significantly or altered the inexorable fact that they were imprisoned by the very circumstance of their birth.”

This is a statement Mr. Conroy made at the very end of the chapter, which is the very end of the book. I chose this sentence because just in these few words it shows how Mr. Conroy felt about his whole experience with the children on Yamacraw. He does not think he made a big difference in their lives because they are in a living position that they could not help. They were born into a life that was bound for no success because of who they were and how their local society was. It is really said to think about knowing that these children are a victim of circumstances that they can not help. In this sentence Mr. Conroy says he does not feel like he changed the quality of their lives. This is true in a way but his job was not to change their living conditions or economic factors. It was to teach them and that he did. These children in my opinion learned more from Mr. Conroy within his one year teaching them than they had in their entire schooling. I believe he was feeling this way because after all this push and fight against Mr. Piedmont and the Board he still did not get the Yamacraw people any help. He did teach the children though and helped the people in more ways than he knew.

This final chapter is Mr. Conroy reflecting back on his experiences the past year on the island. He explains that Mr. Piedmont and Mr. Bennington were not bad people like he thought after all. They were just two men that were stuck in a changing society that they were not used to and did not know how to cope with. He talks about Mrs. Brown and how he hopes she is will be happy for the rest of her life. It is sad that society has made her feel like she should not be proud of who she is and treat her own people so badly. Overall, Mr. Conroy enjoyed his year on Yamacraw Island and learned so much about the people and the changing world around him. 

No comments:

Post a Comment